Dometic Turbo Unit (DTU) vs. EnviroComfort Unit (ECD)
Being Dometic dealers, we know well both the Dometic Turbo DTU and Dometic Envirocomfort ECD – the company’s two most popular self-contained marine air conditioners – quite well. They both come in cooling capacities from 6,000 to 16,000 BTUs, but there are a few key differences. (note: for the Dometic DTG vs CTM CT Unit, see here).
We’re highlighting the pros and cons of both units below:
Dometic Turbo DTU Unit
Powerful, Quiet & Compact With No Drain Pan Worries
The Dometic Turbo DTU series completely revolutionized self-contained boat air conditioning with patented innovations in marine air conditioning system design, winning the IBEX Innovation Award. The rust-free molded composite drain pan has three drains for the rapid removal of condensate water. The drain pan has a small footprint for installation flexibility. A vibration-isolation mounting system results in significantly quieter, virtually vibration-free performance. The enclosed blower motor eliminates overhang for reduced depth.
The Dometic Turbo DTU is available in 6,000, 8,000, 10,000, 12,000 and 16,000 BTU/hr, with the 16,000 BTU Dometic DTU16 being the top seller.
These new and updated versions of the self contained unit also have the dual capability of heating and cooling. Through its reversing valve, the unit can be used as a heater and air conditioner.
Dometic Turbo DTU PROS
- Turbo blower has 30% more capacity
- Compact, lightweight
- Composite drain pan will not rust
- Optional sound cover further reduces compressor noise by up to 50%
- More modern design
- Reverse cycle = cooling and heating
- Slightly further rotation allowed on blower
- New “U-Board” Universal control Board
Dometic Turbo DTU
- Higher price point
- Doesn’t come with control / display or cable because it’s intended to be replacement for previous Dometic models (Stowaway Turbo STX, Vector Turbo Unit VTD)
*Dometic Turbo DTU Units are direct replacements for all VT and ST units. All units include temperature sensor. Display cable not included.
Dometic EnviroComfort – Dometic ECD
Enjoy Year-Round Comfort with EnviroComfort – Dometic ECD
Dometic’s EnviroComfort Units (ECDs) are available in 6,000, 10,000, and 16,000 BTU/hr cooling and reverse-cycle heating capacities, so you can size the system to suit your boat for ultimate comfort in a range of climates.
All units have blowers with internal motors for a more compact installation footprint. The blower can be rotated to a horizontal or vertical position for greater installation flexibility. ECD units are built on an easy-to-plumb stainless-steel drain pan, and the pre-installed return-air filter is removable for cleaning.
Dometic ECD units are operated by a compact digital control/display (included) that features a bright green LED and large buttons. For added installation convenience, the plastic electrical box can be mounted remotely.
ECD kits are ideal for replacing an existing air conditioning system or for a new air conditioning installation. The Retrofit Kit includes the ECD self-contained air conditioning unit and digital control with bezel and is intended to replace an older self-contained air conditioner of comparable capacity. The ECD6K will replace a 5,000 to 7,000 BTU/hr unit; the ECD10K will replace an 8,000 to 11,000 BTU/hr unit, and the ECD16K will replace a 12,000 to 16,000 BTU/hr unit.
Dometic ECD PROS
- More economic price point
- High-velocity blower provides powerful cooling
- Compact, lightweight design
- Control / display and cables included
- New “U-Board” Universal control Board
Dometic ECD CONS
- Pans are stainless but not stainfree – therefore some rusting may occur over time
- No sound cover option
Good Replacement Option for Dometic DTU or ECD Units – CTM CT Units
The CT-Unit from CTM is a new unit in the market that works as a direct replacement for the Dometic DTU or Dometic ECD. The CT Unit offers several advantages that the ECD nor the DTU offer. It comes standard with corrosion-resistant titanium condensing coils and ABS drain pan, high-velocity blower, universal control board (compatible with most Dometic / Cruisair / Marine Air controls), quiet compressor, compact design, and more.
The CTM Units come in either 10,000 or 16,000 BTU’s, 115V and 230V. CTM is offering these units at a competitive price, starting at just $1,699.00. If you want to know more about the CT Units, see here: CTM CT Marine Air Conditioners
Specifications for CTM CT-Units
New “U Control Board” Included with DTU Units:
How to Install Unit Video (DTU and ECD units)
Summary
Key Benefits of DTU’s Compared to ECD’s units:
- Up to 27% more energy efficient
- Up to 21% increased capacity
- Compact design uses less space
- Rust-free composite drain pan
- Up to 85% less standing water in the drain pan
- Vibration-isolation mounts reduce noise and vibration
- Designed from the inside out with multiple patented innovations
- Optional sound cover further reduces compressor noise by up to 50%
Technical Specifications of Dometic DTU16:
Capacity (BTU/h): 16,000
Voltage (V): 115
Cycle (Hz): 60
Phase (Ph): 1
Full Load Amps (FLA) Cool (A): 10.4
Full Load Amps (FLA) Heat (A): 13.6
Full Load Amps (FLA) Blower (A): 1.61
Locked Rotor Amps (LRA) (A): 62
Refrigerant Type: 410A
Height (in): 13.4
Height (mm): 341
Width (in): 21.4
Width (mm): 544
Depth (in): 13.3
Depth (mm): 338
Sound Level: N/A
Dimensions of DTU:
Dometic Turbo Unit Replacement Chart
The Dometic Turbo Unit is a replacement for previous turbo units from Cruisair (Stowaway Turbo Units STX and STQ) and Marine Air (Vector Turbo Unit VTD), two Dometic subsidiaries merging as one Dometic brand. You can find which Dometic Turbo units replace your Cruisair or Marine Air units using the chart below:
115V 60HZ Turbo Units |
|||
NEW Dometic P/N | New Description | Replaces Cruisair & Marine Air P/N | Old Description |
205160060 | DTU6 115V 60HZ 410A | 205561250 205561255 205561200 |
STQ6-410A 115V 60HZ ONLY STX6-410A 115V 60HZ ONLY VTD6K-410A 115V 60HZ ONLY |
205160080 | DTU8 115V 60HZ 410A | 205561350 205561355 205561300 |
STQ8-410A 115V 60HZ ONLY STX8-410A 115V 60HZ ONLY VTD8K-410A 115V 60HZ ONLY |
205160100 | DTU10 115V 60HZ 410A | 205561450 205561455 205561400 |
STQ10-410A 115V 60HZ ONLY STX10-410A 115V 60HZ ONLY VTD10K-410A 115V 60HZ ONLY |
205160120 | DTU12 115V 60HZ 410A | 205561550 205561555 205561500 |
STQ12-410A 115V 60HZ ONLY STX12-410A 115V 60HZ ONLY VTD12K-410A 115V 60HZ ONLY |
205160160 | DTU16 115V 60HZ 410A | 205561750 205561755 205561700 |
STQ16-410A 115V 60HZ ONLY STX16-410A 115V 60HZ ONLY VTD16K-410A 115V 60HZ ONLY |
115V 60HZ Turbo Units with Smart Start |
|||
205160063 | DTU6 115V 60HZ 410A SMRTSTRT | 205561203 | VTD6K-410A 115V SMARTSTART |
205160083 | DTU8 115V 60HZ 410A SMRTSTRT | 205561352 205561303 |
STQ8-410A 115V 60HZ SMARTSTART VTD8K-410A 115V 60HZ W/SMRTST |
205160103 | DTU10 115V 60HZ 410A SMRTSTRT | 205561452 205561403 |
STQ10-410A 115V SMARTSTART-ONBX VTD10K-410A 115V SMRTSTART |
205160123 | DTU12 115V 60HZ 410A SMRTSTRT | 205561552 205561556 205561503 |
STQ12-410A 115V SMARTSTART-ONBX STX12-410A 115V 60HZ SMARTSTART VTD12K-410A 115V SMARTSTART |
205160163 | DTU16 115V 60HZ 410A SMRTSTRT |
205561753 205561756 205561705 |
STQ16-410A 115V SMARTSTART-ONBX STX16-410A 115V 60HZ SMARTSTART VTD16K-410A 115V 60HZ SMARTSTAR |
220V 50HZ Turbo Units with Hose Adapter |
|||
205161061 | DTU6 220V 50HZ 410A 4MR | 205562201 205562251 |
VTD6KZ50-410A 7’AS 4″MR 220V/5 STQ6CK-410A 4″MR 220V/50HZ |
205161081 | DTU8 220V 50HZ 410A 5MR | 205562301 205562351 |
VTD8KZ50-410A 7’AS 5MR 220/50 STQ8CK-410A 5MR 220V 50HZ |
205161101 | DTU10 220V 50HZ 410A 6MR |
205562401 205562451 205562402 |
VTD10KZ50-410A 7’AS 6MR 220/5 STQ10CK-410A 6″MR 220V 50HZ VTD10KZ50-410A 6″MR 220V 50HZ |
205161121 | DTU12 220V 50HZ 410A 6MR | 205562551 205562501 |
STQ12CK-410A 6MR 220V 50HZ VTD12KZ50-410A 7’AS 6MR 220/5 |
205161161 | DTU16 220V 50HZ 410A 7MR | 205562701 205562751 205562756 |
VTD16KZ50-410A 7’AS 7″MR 220V STQ16CK-410A 7″MR 220V 50HZ STX16CK-410A 7″MR 220V 50HZ |
230V 60HZ Turbo Units |
|||
New Dometic P/N | New Description | Replaces Cruisair & Marine Air P/N | Old Description |
205162060 | DTU6 230V 60HZ 410A | 205563250 205563255 205563200 |
STQ6C-410A 230V 60HZ STX6C-410A 230V 60HZ VTD6KZ-410A 230V 60HZ |
205162080 | DTU8 230V 60HZ 410A | 205563350 205563355 205563300 |
STQ8C-410A 230V 60HZ STX8C-410A 230V 60HZ VTD8KZ-410A 230V 60HZ |
205162100 | DTU10 230V 60HZ 410A | 205563550 205563555 205563500 |
STQ12C-410A 230V 60HZ STX12C-410A 230V 60HZ VTD12KZ-410A 230V 60HZ |
205162120 | DTU12 230V 60HZ 410A | 205563550 205563555 205563500 |
STQ12C-410A 230V 60HZ STX12C-410A 230V 60HZ VTD12KZ-410A 230V 60HZ |
205162160 | DTU16 230V 60HZ 410A | 205563750 205563755 205563700 |
STQ16C-410A 230V 60HZ STX16C-410A 230V 60HZ VTD16KZ-410A 230V 60HZ |
230/220V Turbo Units with Smart Start |
|||
205162123 | DTU12 230V 60HZ 410A SMRTSTRT |
205563503 | VTD12KZ-410A 230V SMARTSTART |
205162163 | DTU16 230V 60HZ 410A SMRTSTRT |
205563760 205563703 |
STQ16C-410A 230V SMARTSTRT-ONBX VTD16KZ-410A 230V 60HZ SMRTST |
205161123 | DTU12 220V 50HZ 410A SMRTSTRT |
205562503 | VTD12KZ50-410A SMARTSTAR |
205161163 | DTU16 220V 50HZ 410A SMRTSTRT |
205562703 | VTD16KZ50-410A SMARTSTART |
You can purchase the Dometic DTG from one of Dometic’s authorized dealers on their dealer list, available on Dometic’s website. Internet retailers are not authorized to sell the DTG online.
“Citations to Dometic products are for reference purposes ONLY. Citimarine does NOT sell Dometic products as Citimarine is NOT affiliated with Dometic.”
Have a good one!
4 Comments
205161161
DTU16-2251-410A 7MR dometic ,, 220 / 50hz ,, please quote delivery france price
Hello Tim, please contact sales@citimarine.com. They will be able to better assist you with a price quote, shipping, etc.
Hi,
I am looking to change my Cruisair VTD 16. is this unit a exact replacement? Can I keep my thermostat?
Hello Manuel, the CTM CT-16 is an exact replacement, as is the DTU16. The CTM is compatible with the majority of Dometic’s thermostats, but double check with our sales guys just to ensure compatibility.