Dometic DTG vs Webasto FCF Platinum vs CTM CT Unit – Comparison
CTM has introduced their all new CT Self-Contained Marine Air Conditioners to the market, and a question we often get here is how do the CTM CT Units compare to Dometic’s DTG (previously known as Dometic DTU) Units and Webasto’s FCF Platinum series, two of the most popular self-contained marine air conditioners available.
We’ve put together an analysis comparing different aspects of all three units – the Dometic DTG, CTM CT Unit and Webasto FCF Platinum units.
Size Comparison between Dometic DTG, CTM CT and Webasto FCF Platinum Marine Air Conditioning Units
Taking Dometic’s DTG16 (16,000 BTUs), Webasto’s FCF16 Platinum Series (16,000 BTUs) and comparing it to CTM’s CT-16 (16,000 BTUs) to compare sizes, all three units have a similar footprint, with the Webasto FCF16 a decent bit larger in each dimension than the other two units, and the CTM significantly smaller in width than the rest. The CTM and Dometic weigh approximately the same, and the Webasto FCF Platinum is a good bit heavier. Here are the dimensions and weights of each:
|Dometic DTG16 vs Webasto FCF16 vs CTM CT16 Unit Size Comparison|
|Dometic DTG16||Webasto FCF16||CTM CT16|
Dometic DTG Unit Layout
Webasto FCF Platinum Series Unit Layout
CTM CT Unit Layout
All three units run off of environmentally-friendly, energy-efficient R410A refrigerant.
Comparison of Materials and Design Features
All three units — the Dometic DTG, Webasto FCF Platinum Series and the CTM CT — have durable construction, and are ready for marine-use. The DTG brings a rust-free composite drain pan, while the CTM and Webasto units bring stainless steel structural pans (CTM with ABS tray; used in heavy industrial applications, ABS is extremely resistant to corrosion, weathering and erosion, as well as aqueous acids, alkalis, alcohols and oils).
Webasto FCF Platinum units are epoxy-painted for corrosion protection, while the CTM CT Unit uses corrosion-resistant titanium coils. DTG units use copper coils which are prone to corrosion. As to the benefits of using titanium coils:
“Titanium resists corrosion by seawater to temperatures as high as 500°F (260°C). Titanium tubing, exposed for 16 years to polluted seawater in a surface condenser, was slightly discolored but showed no evidence of corrosion.(8) Titanium has provided over thirty years of trouble-free seawater service for the chemical, oil refining and desalination industries. Exposure of titanium for many years to depths of over a mile below the ocean surface has not produced any measurable corrosion(9)”
Differences in Design and Cooling Efficiency
The CTM unit has an advantage over the other units in design and cooling-efficiency. On Dometic DTG and Webasto FCF Platinum units, air flows through the hot condensing coils before being cooled down by the evaporator, and it is then blown out through the fan — which can cost efficiency. On the CTM CT Unit, room temperature is cooled by the condensing unit and the cool air is pushed through the blower’s tunnel without being affected by the heat of the coils, where it is then blown out by the fan, making the CTM unit more efficient on BTUs.
Energy Consumption Comparison Between the Dometic DTG, Webasto FCF Platinum and CTM CT Units
Both the DTG and CTM CT Units consume approximately the same amperage during startup and use, with the Webasto FCF Platinum Series consuming more upon startup, and a slightly wider range of current consumption cooling reported. All three are available in 115V and 230V voltages and 50/60 Hz frequencies. See comparisons of available energy-use info on the three 115V 16,000 BTU models below.
|Dometic DTG16 vs Webasto FCF16 vs CTM CT16 – Energy-Use Comparison|
|Dometic DTG||Webasto FCF Platinum||CTM CT|
|Frequency||50/60 Hz||50/60 Hz||50/60 Hz|
|Starting Amps (max)||34.6 A||16 A||37.5 A||35 A||29.25 A||16 A|
|Current Consumption Cooling (max)||10.40 – 10.70 A||5.1 A||10.3 – 11.2 A||5.6 – 5.7 A||9.78 – 10.31 A||5.3 A|
|Current Consumption Heating (max)||13.6 A||6.6 A||No info||No info||13.5 A||6.8 A|
|Fuse Min.||25 A||No info||25 A|
|Fuse Max.||40 A||No info||40 A|
Video – Comparison of Performance of Each Unit – Electrical, Temperature, Fan Test & Sound Test
In the video below, you’ll see we tested out each of the units, comparing the performance of each in these different areas.
Price Comparison Between Dometic DTG, Webasto FCF Platinum Series and CTM CT Units
CTM currently offers CT units in 10,000 (CT-10) and 16,000 (CT-16) BTU capacities. We will compare CTM’s CT unit prices for these two models to the same capacity Dometic DTG and Webasto FCF Platinum series models (manufacturer’s price). CTM CT units are significantly lower in price than comparable Dometic DTG and Webasto FCF Platinum Series models of the same capacity.
|Dometic DTG vs CTM CT Unit Price Comparisons|
|Model||Dometic DTG||Webasto FCF Platinum||CTM CT|
|10,000 BTU, 115V||$2,940||$2,210||$1,869|
|10,000 BTU, 230V||$2,990||$2,210||$1,929|
|16,000 BTU, 115V||$3,145||$2,662||$2,089|
|16,000 BTU, 230V||$3,400||$2,662||$2,149|
Where to Buy CTM CT Marine Air Conditioners
The Dometic DTG can be purchased from one of Dometic’s authorized dealers on their dealer list, available on Dometic’s website. Internet retailers are not authorized to sell the DTG online.*
We carry CTM CT-10 and CT-16 Units, here: CTM CT Marine Air Conditioners. Compatible with Dometic and Cruisair’s controls and cables. Free US Shipping.
Have a good one!
3300 NW 112th Ave, #4
Doral, FL 33172
*Citations to Dometic products are for reference purposes ONLY. Citimarine does NOT sell Dometic products as Citimarine is NOT affiliated with Dometic.